When to fish Montauk
Each row is shaded against that species' own best month here, so a dark cell means a good month for that fish rather than a comparison between them.
Relative abundance by month for each species around Montauk| Species | JJanuary | FFebruary | MMarch | AApril | MMay | JJune | JJuly | AAugust | SSeptember | OOctober | NNovember | DDecember |
|---|
| Striped Bass | | | | | | | | | | | | |
|---|
| Fluke | | | | | | | | | | | | |
|---|
| Bluefish | | | | | | | | | | | | |
|---|
| False Albacore | | | | | | | | | | | | |
|---|
| Black Sea Bass | | | | | | | | | | | | |
|---|
| Yellowfin Tuna | | | | | | | | | | | | |
|---|
| Blackfish | | | | | | | | | | | | |
|---|
Striped Bass: January none, February none, March none, April poor, May peak, June peak, July peak, August excellent, September peak, October peak, November excellent, December none. Fluke: January none, February none, March none, April none, May fair, June peak, July peak, August peak, September peak, October fair, November none, December none. Bluefish: January none, February none, March none, April none, May fair, June peak, July peak, August peak, September peak, October peak, November good, December none. False Albacore: January none, February none, March none, April none, May none, June none, July fair, August peak, September peak, October peak, November poor, December none. Black Sea Bass: January none, February none, March none, April fair, May peak, June peak, July peak, August peak, September peak, October peak, November fair, December none. Yellowfin Tuna: January none, February none, March none, April none, May none, June fair, July peak, August peak, September peak, October peak, November none, December none. Blackfish: January none, February none, March none, April excellent, May peak, June good, July good, August good, September peak, October peak, November excellent, December poor.
- Striped Bass. Montauk stripers are nearly absent in winter, when the migratory stock is off Virginia and the Carolinas, leaving only a few holdovers. A spring peak in mid-to-late May follows the arrival of sand eels and squid, and summer stays moderate as fish hold on the deep rips and feed at night. The biggest peak is the late September through October fall run, when migrating fish blitz on bay anchovies and peanut bunker off the Point before departing by early December.
- Fluke. Summer flounder (fluke) winter offshore along the continental shelf edge and are effectively absent from Montauk's inshore and nearshore waters from December through mid-April. Fish begin arriving in late April and fill in through May and June as the water warms. Abundance peaks from July through mid-August, when larger fish stack on the rips, ledges, and wrecks off the Point. Numbers then decline steadily through September and into October as fluke migrate offshore.
- Bluefish. Bluefish are absent from Montauk in winter and arrive in early-to-mid May as waters pass about 55°F, producing a late-May/June spring peak of big choppers. Numbers dip slightly in midsummer as fish spread out, then build through late summer as snappers and adult fish feed on peanut bunker, mullet and bay anchovies. The fall run peaks from late September through mid-October, then fish depart by late November as water temperatures drop.
- False Albacore. Little tunny (false albacore) are warm-water migrants that are absent from Montauk waters through winter and spring, with the first fish typically showing in late June or early July as water temperatures climb. Numbers build through August and peak from late August through early October, when bay anchovy and silverside schools concentrate around Montauk Point. They taper off quickly once water temperatures drop below roughly 60°F in late October and November.
- Black Sea Bass. Black sea bass migrate inshore to Montauk's rock piles and wrecks as water warms in late April–May. They spawn in late May and June, and abundance stays solid through summer. A second peak comes in September–October, when fish stage on deeper structure before moving offshore to the shelf edge as water cools in November. Only a few fish linger on deep offshore wrecks through winter.
- Yellowfin Tuna. Yellowfin push onto the shelf and canyons south of Montauk (Coxes Ledge, Butterfish Hole, Dip, Fishtails) as Gulf Stream eddies warm offshore waters in early June. They peak from late June through July and again in late August into early September with sand eel, squid, and butterfish bait. They thin out through October as water cools and are absent from November through May.
- Blackfish. Montauk tautog are largely resident and stay on local rocky structure year-round. Numbers on the nearshore reefs and jetties build as water warms past about 50°F in late April and May, when fish move shallow to spawn. They hold steady through summer, then peak again from October into mid-November when fish feed heavily on crabs and mussels before shifting to deeper offshore wrecks in winter (lower but nonzero presence).